Comparison · 2026

The best trading journal for prop-firm traders

Almost every journal here is good at the same job: logging trades and computing your stats. For a funded trader the deciding question is different — does it actually stop you breaching a rule, and does it scale across accounts? Here's the honest matrix, then who each tool is really for.

	Shibiki	TradeZella	Tradervue	TraderSync	Journali	Edgewonk	Spreadsheet
Auto trade sync from broker
Analytics & reporting
Edge confidence interval (Wilson)
Backtesting / trade replay
Psychology analytics
Prop-firm rule tracking
Risk enforced at the broker
Copier across prop accounts

Full Partial / limited Not available — judged on stable, public capabilities; confirm current features with each vendor.

Who each tool is for

Shibiki

Best for funded traders

The only tool here that enforces your risk at the broker instead of just alerting you, runs a copier across your prop accounts, and tells you whether your edge is statistically real with a Wilson confidence interval. If you're managing evaluations and funded accounts, that's the difference between a rough Friday and a blown account.

Start free Try the drawdown calculator →

TradeZella

Best for: Reviewing and backtesting trades in a polished, modern UI.

Shibiki vs TradeZella →

Tradervue

Best for: A dependable, established all-round journal with broad imports.

Shibiki vs Tradervue →

TraderSync

Best for: Deep analytics plus a market-replay simulator to practise setups.

Shibiki vs TraderSync →

Journali

Best for: Prop-firm-focused tracking across multiple evaluation accounts.

Shibiki vs Journali →

Edgewonk

Best for: Working on trading psychology, on a one-time license.

Shibiki vs Edgewonk →

How to choose

If you trade one account casually and want the best pure review and backtesting experience, TradeZella or TraderSync are hard to beat. If you want to work on psychology and prefer a one-time license, Edgewonk is a thoughtful pick. Tradervue is the safe, established all-rounder.

But if you're running prop-firm evaluations or funded accounts, the journal that only records your trades leaves the two hardest problems unsolved: not breaching a live rule, and not re-keying every trade across accounts. That's the gap Shibiki is built for — check your headroom with the drawdown calculator or confirm your edge is real with the expectancy calculator.

FAQ

What's the best free trading journal?

A spreadsheet is the free default, and Shibiki has a free plan you can start on today. The trade-off with a spreadsheet is everything automatic — broker sync, live edge stats, and anything that acts on your risk in real time.

Which journal is best for prop-firm / funded traders?

Look for prop-rule tracking, multi-account support, and — the piece almost no journal has — risk that's enforced at the broker rather than flagged after the fact. That combination is what Shibiki was built around; Journali is the closest competitor on positioning.

Do I still need a journal if my prop firm has a dashboard?

A firm dashboard shows their view of your account, not your edge by setup or whether it's statistically real. A journal that computes expectancy with a confidence interval answers a question the firm's dashboard never will.

In depth: vs TradeZella · vs Tradervue · vs TraderSync · vs Journali · vs Edgewonk · vs a spreadsheet