Shibiki vs Journali
Journali is a newer journal built around prop-firm workflows and edge-by-setup analytics — the closest in positioning to Shibiki. Both tools journal your trades and compute your stats — so this comparison is about the one thing that genuinely sets them apart.
| Journali | Shibiki | |
|---|---|---|
| Trade journaling & analytics | ||
| Prop-firm rule tracking | ||
| Risk enforced at the broker | ||
| Copier across prop accounts | ||
| Live edge health (Wilson CI) |
Full Partial / limited Not available
What Journali does well
- Prop-firm-oriented journaling and rule tracking
- Edge-by-setup performance breakdowns
- Multi-account tracking for prop traders
Where Shibiki is different
Most journals — Journali included — record your trading. Shibiki also acts on it:
- Shibiki doesn't just track your prop rules — it enforces them at the broker before you breach.
- It copies one master across your prop accounts, not just tracks each one separately.
- Live edge health with a Wilson confidence interval to tell a real edge from a lucky streak.
Bottom line
Journali and Shibiki target the same trader. The difference is action: Journali tracks your prop rules; Shibiki also enforces them at the broker and copies your strategy across accounts.
Other comparisons: vs TradeZella · vs Tradervue · vs TraderSync · vs Edgewonk · the full roundup