Shibiki vs Edgewonk
Edgewonk is a boutique journal focused on trading psychology and prescriptive analytics, sold as a one-time license. Both tools journal your trades and compute your stats — so this comparison is about the one thing that genuinely sets them apart.
| Edgewonk | Shibiki | |
|---|---|---|
| Trade journaling & analytics | ||
| Deep psychology analytics | ||
| Risk enforced at the broker | ||
| Copier across prop accounts | ||
| Live edge health (Wilson CI) |
Full Partial / limited Not available
What Edgewonk does well
- Deep psychology and behavioural analytics
- Prescriptive 'what to work on next' feedback
- A one-time license instead of a subscription
Where Shibiki is different
Most journals — Edgewonk included — record your trading. Shibiki also acts on it:
- Enforces your risk limits at the broker — not just an alert, an actual hard stop before you breach.
- Copies one master strategy across multiple prop-firm accounts, no re-keying.
- Live edge health with a Wilson confidence interval, so you know whether your edge is statistically real or a small-sample streak.
Bottom line
Edgewonk is a thoughtful journal for working on your psychology, and its one-time license is genuinely appealing. Shibiki is a different tool — it connects to your broker to enforce risk and copy across prop accounts, which a self-contained journal can't.
Other comparisons: vs TradeZella · vs Tradervue · vs TraderSync · vs Journali · the full roundup